Welcome to Casey's Pizza
At Casey's Pizza, located in the heart of San Francisco, a passion for authentic East Coast-style pizza comes to life. Founded by Casey, whose vision flourished from a food truck to a beloved brick-and-mortar establishment, this pizzeria delights guests with its inviting ambiance and friendly service. Each dish showcases fresh, high-quality ingredients, exemplified by standout options like the East Coast Pie and the creamy burrata salad. The emphasis on detail, from the perfectly thin and crispy crust to the vibrant toppings, ensures a memorable dining experience. Whether you're dining in or enjoying takeout, Casey's Pizza is your new go-to for exceptional pizza in Mission Bay.
-
1170 4th St, San Francisco, CA 94158 Hotline: (415) 814-2482
Welcome to Casey's Pizza, a vibrant slice of culinary heaven tucked away at 1170 4th St, San Francisco, CA 94158. This charming pizzeria has quickly become a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts across the city. With its warm ambiance and welcoming staff, Casey's Pizza successfully captures the essence of East Coast-style pizza, all while maintaining a cozy atmosphere perfect for gatherings or solo dining.
Upon entering, you are greeted with the enticing aroma of freshly baked pizza and the inviting smiles of the staff. According to loyal patrons, the friendly service is just as noteworthy as the delectable fare. As Yuvraj P. aptly described, "You can feel that all the ingredients in the pizza are super quality," which is evident in every dish.
Starters at Casey's Pizza feature a delightful array of fresh ingredients that set the stage for the main event. Popular choices include the Burrata Salad ($18) with its creamy texture and peppery arugula, and the refreshing Jersey Salad ($22) that never fails to impress. These appetizers perfectly complement the variety of pizzas available, each crafted with care and attention to detail.
- Bianca: A creamy delight at $25.
- Hot Pie: A must-try for bold flavors at $33.
- Margherita: A classic favorite priced at $24.50.
- East Coast Pie: A delectable choice featuring quality ingredients at $28.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment that the pizza at Casey's is truly exceptional. Brought to life with the perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and quality toppings, each pie is a testament to the artistry of pizza making. Vrinda A. raves about the fresh, hot New York-style pie, while Jody S. declares it to be the best pizza they've enjoyed in ages.
For those who relish a little spice, the Spicy Pie ($32) offers a fantastic combination of flavors, and the signature Bacon Kale Pie ($32) is a standout for its unique ingredients. As mentioned by Belinda W., while the prices may lean toward the higher end, the quality and flavor of each pizza justify the cost.
Located conveniently near the Chase Center and Oracle Park, Casey's Pizza is perfect for game days or leisurely evenings. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery through popular apps, there’s no shortage of ways to enjoy these culinary creations. A charming arcade cabinet in the back adds an element of fun, inviting customers to linger just a bit longer.
For the best experience, remember to visit during happy hour for discounted beverages, and be patient on busy nights; good things come to those who wait! With the delightful cuisine, impeccable service, and a warm atmosphere, Casey's Pizza is a must-try for any pizza lover in San Francisco.
Came here for my birthday after an invite from my friend "Rafa". As soon as we walked in the owner & staff were very welcoming and friendly. first we tried the baby lettuce and the burrata salad they were both Delicious with fresh ingredients and full of flavors. However that was just the beginning, the PIZZA here was just SO GOOD!!! One of the best pizzas I've tried in SF. Also The place was really clean and well decorated. Overall such a Great experience. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!
This place is fantastic! The New York pie is delicious and the pizza always comes out fresh, hot, and the perfect amount of crispy! Staff is friendly and great. Shout out to Christine for being the best!
I think we found a new pizza joint for amazing thin crust. A little on the pricier side (ranging from $23-32 for one size) for a whole pie without additional toppings. However, you pay for a quality east coast pie. The crust was thin and crispy, and the sausage add-on was flavorful. We ordered the spicy pie ($31+) online and customized it to our liking. It was such a tasty pie and I am sure we will be ordering again very soon. Just make sure to give them an additional 10 min if you're ordering for pickup on a busy weekend or game night.
Delicious Pizza! I'm so glad that we discovered this place. It's the best pizza that we've had in ages. Perfect balance of sauce, cheese and toppings, along with a perfect crust. It's definitely our new go to for our pizza deliveries! And it's nicely located near the Caltrain station. So when I have friends come visit me via train, it will be the perfect place to meet up! Well done Casey's Pizza, well done!!
You can feel that all the ingredients in the pizza are super quality. Very similar to the pizza I used to eat in Italy. I really liked the amount of the cheese and topping which was not too much so you can taste the sauce.
I have dined in once and ordered takeout multiple times from here, and it's always a great experience. They offer delivery service through Uber Eats and Doordash, as well as pick-up service through these apps and their website. The ambiance inside is very cozy and homey. When I dined at the restaurant, they were offering a discount to students and employees at the nearby institution where I study. I wasn't aware of this and didn't have my student ID on hand. When I mentioned this to the owner, Casey at the cashier, he kindly offered me the discount anyway, saying he trusted me, which was so sweet and thoughtful. The entire crew is very friendly! Here are my go-to orders: Jersey Salad: Casey said this is his favorite, and now it has become one of mine. Perfect for when you are in the mood for something different. East Coast Pie: This would be my ultimate recommendation if you are a thin-crust and pepperoni fan like I am! Spicy Pie: I have a very low spice tolerance, but despite the name, it was not as spicy. The honey and ricotta combination is fantastic! The restaurant is within walking distance from both Chase Center and Oracle Park. I highly recommend stopping by before or after a game/concert or just dining in/taking out if you live/work nearby!
Delicious pizzas. The Hot Pie in particular (not to be confused with the Spicy Pie or the Spicy Bianca) is incredible. I split one with a few friends who aren't usually fans of white pies, and they still loved it! The blackboard shows most of the menu, but it doesn't make it obvious which ones are red vs. white pies. The actual menus do, and might be worth cross-referencing. The shop itself is cute; they've got an arcade cabinet in the back, too. They aren't the best with large orders; we ended up waiting over half an hour for our orders. They do have a deal on Tuesdays though, which helps with the high pricing.
DELICIOUS PIZZA!!! great ambiance as well. it gets pretty busy, lots of foot traffic for dinner. staff was friendly. the bianca pizza was so creamy and rich. love the hot honey and pepperoni combination on the wise gal. crust of the pizza was crisp, just a tad burnt. Casey's sundae was really unique and loved the complementing flavor and texture profiles from the olive oil, cherries, and almonds with the vanilla ice cream. would def pop by again after work, just loved the vibe! DEF CHECK THIS PLACE OUT
The best pizza in SF! If you are in Mission Bay for a game I highly recommend this place. The best pizza I've ever had is from Pasty's off 116th and 1st Ave in NY. This is very comparable. Even better.
3.5 STARS Salad and pizza are the obligatory combo. Because the salad cancels out the pizza. At least, in my delusory life. But, hey...at least you're getting greens in! I've had Casey's Pizza Truck bookmarked for over a decade but never made it. The owner has since opened a brick & mortar in 2017 serving his East-Coast Style Pizzas. If you're driving to Casey's Pizza, def recommend checking to see if there's an event at the Chase Center and Oracle on the day you visit. Traffic and parking will otherwise be a nightmare. Casey's Pizza is open for takeout, delivery, indoor dining, and dog-friendly outdoor dining (parklet). Fast-casual service; order at the counter and your order will be brought to you. M E N U Olives ($10), Salads ($17), and Pizzas ($24-$31). Happy hour: 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm (discounted booze). Self-serve water. Craft beer and wine available. F O O D * Burrata Salad: Fresh burrata w/ arugula, housemade crostini, extra virgin olive oil, lemon juice, pepper ($17): https://tinyurl.com/mrxjjfcs You can't really go wrong with milky rich, creamy burrata with peppery arugula. Couldn't taste the lemon juice tho. * East Coast Pie w/ Ezzo cupping pepperoni, fresh+aged mozzarella, red sauce, grana padano, thyme, basil ($28.50): https://tinyurl.com/yj3w3khp --Add sausage (+$4.50) Tasty pizza with good ratio of ingredients, zesty tomato sauce, stretchy cheese, and flavorful Ezzo pepperoni + fennel sausage. Crisp chewy crust, heartier than your usual Neapolitan. It was kinda dry so the Mike's hot honey came in handy for dipping. I usually don't like pepperoni except Ezzo's that packs meaty flavor without being hella salty. It didn't cup to form those delicious charred edges tho. One 14" pizza (6 slices) is good for one hangry person. For two, gotta order a salad to supplement. S E R V I C E Cordial but slow (weeknight around 5 pm). The couple in line before us, ate and left...and we didn't receive our salad yet. After finishing our salad and waiting for a bit, our pizza didn't come out so I had to go inside to inquire about it. It came out about 5 minutes later. A M B I A N C E Casual, cozy date night vibes with 8-9 two tops and counter seating overlooking the open kitchen. P A R K I N G Metered street parking. Easier on non-event days but can be challenging after 5 pm. Overall, solid East-Coast Style Pizza but steep pricing for a fast-casual pizza eatery. After tip, it was close to $69 for a salad + pizza but you're supporting a small local business so 3.5 stars rounded up.